Zomeable 4-polytopes

Zomeable orthographic projections of uniform 4-polytopes

This project enumerates all distinct 3D shapes obtainable by orthographic projection of each convex regular 4-polytope, such that every projected edge lies on a default-color zometool axis (B / Y / R / G in the icosahedral system).

Master result

The 8 polytopes documented below are the regulars + non-Wythoff corpus. For the full Wythoff family (47 unique convex uniform 4-polytopes including all of the rectified / truncated / cantellated / runcinated descendants), see WYTHOFF_SWEEP.md and the inheritance-free corpus-completeness audit in INHERITANCE_FREE_SWEEP.md.

Polytope Verts Edges Distinct shapes Notes
5-cell {3,3,3} 5 10 4 saturated rng=3; matches Richter/Vorthmann 2007
8-cell {4,3,3} 16 32 1 inf family + 3 sporadic inf family = split cuboids parametrized by ℤ[φ]-Pythagorean triples (a:b) with a²+b²=c²∈ℤ[φ]; sporadics = cube, rhombic dodec, phi-oblique (V=16, kernel support 3)
16-cell {3,3,4} 8 24 6 saturated rng=4
24-cell {3,4,3} 24 96 3 saturated rng=3
120-cell {5,3,3} 600 1200 1 saturated rng=3 (330-ball image)
600-cell {3,3,5} 120 720 1 saturated rng=4 (75-ball image)
Snub 24-cell 96 432 2 cell-first Tₕ, vertex-first D₃d
Grand antiprism 100 500 2 vertex-first D₂ₕ, ring-first D₅d

(See per-polytope RESULTS.md files under output/<polytope>/ for details.)

Methodology

For each polytope P:

  1. Embed P in ℝ⁴ with rational/algebraic vertices.
  2. Enumerate kernel directions n ∈ ℤ[φ]⁴ with |a|, |b| ≤ rng for each component a + bφ, deduplicated by sign-flip-per-axis and decreasing magnitude.
  3. For each direction, compute the 3×4 orthographic projection matrix Q, project all edges to 3D, check whether all |cos∠| between projected edge directions are among the 40 allowed values for default-axis pairs, then attempt to align two non-parallel edges to a chosen default-axis pair and verify all remaining edges land on default axes.
  4. Group hits by rotation+uniform-scale-invariant shape fingerprint (sorted multiset of normalized pairwise squared distances).
  5. Increase rng until shape count stabilizes (“saturation”).

See METHODOLOGY.md for caveats about empirical-vs-formal saturation.

Code layout

zomeable-4polytopes\
├── lib\
│   ├── polytopes.py             vertex/edge specifications for all 8 polytopes
│   ├── search_engine.py         generic kernel-direction search
│   ├── run_search.py            CLI runner: python lib/run_search.py <name> [rng]
│   ├── emit_generic.py          generic <Polytope4d>-based emitter
│   ├── emit_vzome.py            hand-built emitter (24-cell)
│   ├── emit_8cell.py            8-cell emitter
│   ├── emit_snub24.py           snub 24-cell emitter
│   └── emit_grand_antiprism.py  grand antiprism emitter
├── tools\
│   ├── fingerprint_audit.py     cross-polytope consistency check
│   └── patch_origin.py          idempotent origin-ball cleanup
├── docs\
│   ├── SUMMARY.md               this file
│   ├── METHODOLOGY.md           saturation & open questions
│   ├── UNIFORM_PLAN.md          extension to all 47 convex uniform 4-polytopes
│   ├── WYTHOFF_SWEEP.md         Wythoff-family corpus: methodology, taxonomy, per-polytope tables
│   └── INHERITANCE_FREE_SWEEP.md  38-hour matrix sweep auditing the Wythoff corpus for completeness
└── output\
    ├── 5cell\           RESULTS.md  + 4 .vZome files
    ├── 8cell\           CLASSIFICATION.md + 9 .vZome files
    ├── 16cell\          RESULTS.md  + 6 .vZome files
    ├── 24cell\          ZOMEABLE_PROJECTIONS.md + 3 .vZome files
    ├── 120cell\         RESULTS.md  + 1 .vZome file
    ├── 600cell\         RESULTS.md  + 1 .vZome file
    ├── snub_24cell\      RESULTS.md  + 2 .vZome files
    ├── grand_antiprism\ RESULTS.md  + 2 .vZome files
    ├── <wythoff descendants>\    39 folders (e.g. rectified_5cell, bitruncated_8cell,
    │                             omnitruncated_120cell, …), each with RESULTS.md
    │                             plus 0–3 .vZome files — see WYTHOFF_SWEEP.md
    └── wythoff_sweep_manifest.json   provenance ledger for the 69 Wythoff-descendant .vZome files

Two notions of “zomeable”

Two distinct criteria show up; the 8-cell case forced us to make the distinction explicit:

  1. Zometool-axis-aligned (the search-engine criterion). Every projected edge direction is one of the 31 default zome axes (B, Y, R, G families). Equivalent to: the 4 image vectors c_i can be rotated so each unit-vector lies on a default axis.
  2. vZome-embeddable (the strict criterion). Additionally, after rotation, every ball coordinate lies in ℤ[φ]³ (up to a single global scale). Equivalent to: every length ratio |c_i|/|c_j| is in ℚ(φ).

The search engine reports criterion 1. Criterion 2 is verified at emit time by the per-strut classify_direction check in emit_vzome.py (every directed strut must match a (B/Y/R/G)i_proto * GF(...)).

Most polytopes satisfy 1 ⇔ 2 because their geometry forces the length ratios to be in ℚ(φ) automatically. The 8-cell breaks this: the search finds support-3 kernels (e.g. n = (1,−1,1,0)) whose 4 image vectors all align with default axes but have length ratios √2/√3 ∉ ℚ(φ) or √(2+φ) ∉ ℚ(φ) — so they exist as zometool sculptures but cannot be expressed in vZome’s standard icosahedral field. We do not emit such cases.

vZome embedding gotchas (learned from 8-cell hand-built emission)

vZome files emitted

All non-hand-built files use vZome’s <Polytope4d> element with a specific Coxeter group + wythoff index + quaternion. The quaternion q is derived from the kernel direction n of the projection by q = conj(n) = (n_w, -n_i, -n_j, -n_k) (vZome’s projection is v ↦ imag(v · q), kernel = span(conj(q))).

Polytope Group / wythoff Files
5-cell A4 / 1000 5cell/5cell_*.vZome (4 files)
16-cell B4/C4 / 1000 16cell/16cell_*.vZome (6 files)
24-cell F4 / 1000 24cell/*.vZome (3 hand-built)
120-cell H4 / 1000 120cell/120cell_H4_to_H3.vZome
600-cell H4 / 0001 600cell/600cell_H4_to_H3.vZome

Caveat: kernel directions in our search embedding may differ from vZome’s internal embedding (vZome uses a Coxeter group’s standard realization). The emitted files were built using each polytope’s standard ℤ[φ] embedding, which matches vZome for {16,24,120,600}-cells but may need reframing for the 5-cell. Each file should be opened in vZome and verified to render with default-color struts; shapes that fail need either (a) a different quaternion in the same family, or (b) a hand-built <ShowPoint>/<JoinPointPair> model (see 24cell/search/emit_vzome.py for the pattern).

Status

External references

Independent prior work corroborating our enumerations: