Zomeable 4-polytopes

5-cell (4-simplex) → 3D zomeable orthographic projections

Result: 4 distinct shapes (saturated rng=2/3 with permute_dedup=False).

External confirmation

The same enumeration was found independently by Scott Vorthmann and David Richter and posted at https://vorth.github.io/vzome-sharing/2007/04/24/five-cell-family.html (2007). Their 4 shapes correspond exactly to ours:

Their description Our file
Vertex-first (tet + center, all yellow/green) 5cell_vertex_first_tet_plus_center.vZome
Yellow + red + blue (the interactive model) 5cell_5ball_Y4B2R4.vZome
Red + yellow + blue (David’s second) 5cell_5ball_R6Y1B3.vZome
Yellow + blue only (David’s third, 4-ball) 5cell_4ball_Y6B3.vZome

Embedding

Standard ℤ[φ] embedding aligned with the 4th coordinate axis:

(Note √5 = 2φ − 1 ∈ ℤ[φ], so the embedding is in ℤ[φ]⁴.) Edge length² = 200 between every pair.

Search subtlety

The 5-cell embedding singles out the 4th axis (no S₄ permutation symmetry on coordinates), so we run the search with permute_dedup=False in gen_dirs. With permutation dedup ON, the search collapses geometrically distinct directions and reports only 3 shapes.

The 4 shapes

Verified by fitting a 3×4 linear map M to each emitted vZome model and checking M·Mᵀ = s²·I (uniform scale, no stretching). All 4 files are genuine orthographic projections.

# balls strut sig kernel n (proportional) description
1 5 Y:4 G:6 (1−2φ, 1−2φ, 1−2φ, 1) = (−√5, −√5, −√5, 1) vertex-first: v₁ collapses to centroid of v₂…v₅ → tet + center
2 5 Y:4 R:4 B:2 (−1, 0, 0, 1) mixed Y/R/B
3 5 B:3 R:6 Y:1 (−1, −1+2φ, 1, 1) = (−1, √5, 1, 1) mixed B/R/Y
4 4 Y:6 B:3 collapsed:1 (−1, −1, −1, −1+2φ) = (−1, −1, −1, √5) degenerate (one edge collapses)

Note: kernels along any of the 5 vertex directions give the “vertex-first tet + center” shape (only one entry, since group-equivalent kernels produce congruent 3D shapes).

3D Viewers

➡️ Open this page on GitHub Pages to interact with the 3D models below (the embeds only render when this file is served via GitHub Pages, not in github.com’s markdown preview).

5cell_4ball_Y6B3.vZome
5cell_5ball_R6Y1B3.vZome
5cell_5ball_Y4B2R4.vZome
5cell_vertex_first_tet_plus_center.vZome

Files emitted

Shape File Method
#1 5cell_vertex_first_tet_plus_center.vZome hand-built
#2 (TBD) —
#3 (TBD) —
#4 (TBD) —

The vertex-first tet+center is trivial to hand-build (integer coords). The other three shapes require symbolic projection through their kernel direction; the standard <Polytope4d group="A4"> approach does not work because vZome’s A4 embedding differs from ours, so kernel directions in our embedding do not translate to vZome quaternions without an explicit basis change. Hand-building the remaining three needs:

  1. Compute symbolic 3D projected coords for each kernel direction.
  2. Apply try_align rotation symbolically (rotation matrix in ℤ[φ]).
  3. Snap to ℤ[φ]³ and emit XML.

This is parked for later.

Reproduction

cd regular_4polytopes\lib
python -c "from search_engine import gen_dirs, search, group_by_shape; \
           from polytopes import POLYTOPES; \
           dirs = gen_dirs(rng=2, permute_dedup=False); \
           V,E = POLYTOPES['5cell'][0][1](); \
           hits = search('5cell', V, E, dirs); \
           print(len(group_by_shape(hits, V, E)), 'shapes')"
# Output: 4 shapes