Zomeable 4-polytopes

Snub 24-cell: zomeable projections to 3D

The snub 24-cell {3,4,3}/2 is one of two non-Wythoff convex uniform 4-polytopes. It has 96 vertices, 432 edges, 480 faces (96 triangles + 384 faces from icosahedral cells), 144 cells (24 icosahedra + 120 tetrahedra), and symmetry group of order 1152 (the snub-24 symmetry group, related to D₄ < F₄ by index 6).

It is built by alternation of the truncated 24-cell, so its edge structure is fundamentally non-root: edges live in directions outside the F₄ root system. This makes it the prime candidate (along with the grand antiprism) for genuinely new zomeable orthographic projections beyond those of the 6 regular 4-polytopes.

Result: 2 distinct zomeable shapes

Empirical search on direction grid up to rng=4 finds exactly 2 distinct zomeable orthographic projections, each verified strict- orthographic by the M·Mᵀ = s²·I test:

For front-visible variants that remove geometry hidden from the positive side of each projection kernel, see ../snub_24cell_hidden_cells/RESULTS.md.

File Kernel direction 3D balls 4D edges → 3D struts Strut counts
snub_24cell_cell_first.vZome (1, 0, 0, 0) 60 432 → 228 B:72 Y:84 R:72
snub_24cell_vertex_first.vZome (φ², φ, 1, 0) 69 432 → 312 B:90 Y:102 R:120

Both projections use all three default zometool colors (blue, yellow, red) — a richer color signature than any of the regular 4-polytope projections, reflecting the snub’s symmetry breaking that mixes pentagonal (red), tetrahedral (yellow), and rectilinear (blue) features.

Projection 1: cell-first (60 balls)

Kernel: (1, 0, 0, 0). This direction is the center of one of the 24 icosahedral cells of the snub 24-cell. It is also exactly a vertex of the removed inscribed 24-cell (recall: snub 24-cell = 600-cell minus a 24-cell, and the removed 24-cell vertices become the icosahedral cell centers).

Projecting along this axis squashes the icosahedral cell at +e₁ and the antipodal one at −e₁ onto the 3D origin. 96 vertices → 60 distinct 3D points (36 collapses; 12 zero-length antipodal-edge collapses).

Found in 80 distinct kernel directions at rng=4 (the orbit of the cell-center direction under the snub-24’s symmetry group).

3D point group: Tₕ (pyritohedral, order 24). The proper rotation group is the chiral tetrahedral T (order 12: E, 8C₃, 3C₂); inversion lifts this to Tₕ. Despite the kernel (1,0,0,0) having a 4-fold cubic stabilizer in the parent 24-cell, the snub’s 24+24 tetrahedral cell- pair pattern breaks the 4-fold to a 3-fold + 2-fold, giving the same symmetry as a pyritohedron.

Relation to 24-cell projections. The kernel (1, 0, 0, 0) plays three different roles depending on which polytope it is applied to:

Polytope What (1,0,0,0) is Resulting 3D shape
24-cell long-root (verts ±eᵢ±eⱼ) a short-root direction = octahedral cell center cuboctahedron (18 balls)
24-cell short-root (verts ±eᵢ and (±½)⁴, the inscribed 24-cell removed from the 600-cell) a vertex direction rhombic dodecahedron (15 balls)
snub 24-cell a cell center (icosahedral cell) the 60-ball shape above

So the snub’s cell-first projection does not coincide with the zomeable cell-first projection of the 24-cell (the 18-ball cuboctahedron lives in the long-root embedding). Instead, the snub’s cell centers are positioned at the vertices of the removed short-root 24-cell, so the snub’s cell-first kernel coincides with that 24-cell’s vertex-first kernel. The two 3D shadows along (1,0,0,0) — the snub’s 60-ball figure and the rhombic-dodecahedron of the inscribed short-root 24-cell — are different shapes; they share only the kernel direction, not a containment relation at canonical ϕ-power scales.

Projection 2: vertex-first (69 balls)

Kernel: (φ², φ, 1, 0). After normalization: (φ/2, 1/2, 1/(2φ), 0), which is exactly a snub 24-cell vertex (it is one of the even permutations of (φ, 1, 1/φ, 0)/2).

Projecting along a vertex direction collapses that vertex and its antipode onto the 3D origin, with the remaining 94 vertices giving 67 more distinct 3D points (after 27 further collapses; 6 of which are zero-length edge collapses). Total 69 balls.

Found in 20 distinct kernel directions at rng=4.

3D point group: D₃d (antiprismatic, order 12). The proper rotation group is D₃ (order 6: E, 2C₃, 3C₂) with the principal 3-fold aligned along the kernel; central inversion lifts it to D₃d.

Where are the deleted 24-cell vertices? Of the 24 deleted 4D vertices (the inscribed 24-cell removed to form the snub), 18 land exactly on kept-vertex shadow positions and only 6 visible holes remain. All 6 visible holes lie on the outer equator (axial coord along the kernel = 0) at the maximum perp radius 1.0, occupying 6 of the 30 evenly-spaced slots on the unit circle (the other 24 are kept balls). This is the same camouflage effect seen in the grand antiprism vertex-first projection (see grand_antiprism/RESULTS.md): vertex-first projections of any diminished 600-cell hide most of the deleted vertices via overlap with kept-vertex shadows.

Both shapes inherit from the 600-cell’s single zomeable projection

Since snub-24 vertices = 600-cell vertices \ inscribed-24-cell vertices, every snub edge is a 600-cell edge. So every zomeable kernel of the 600-cell is automatically zomeable for the snub.

The 600-cell has exactly one zomeable orthographic shape (one H₄ orbit of kernel directions, the H₄→H₃ projection with 75 distinct balls). Both kernels (1, 0, 0, 0) and (φ², φ, 1, 0) belong to this single H₄ orbit and give the same 75-ball figure for the 600-cell.

Under the snub’s smaller symmetry group (order 1152, an index-12 sub-orbit structure of H₄), the single H₄ orbit splits into two orbits — precisely matching the two snub shapes (60 and 69 balls). Empirically:

Polytope n=(1,0,0,0) n=(φ²,φ,1,0)
600-cell 75 balls (cell/vertex/face/edge — all related under H₄) 75 balls (same shape)
snub-24 60 balls (cell-first) 69 balls (vertex-first)
24-cell long-root 18 balls (cuboctahedron, cell-first) MISS (kernel not zomeable)
24-cell short-root 15 balls (rhombic dodec, vertex-first) HIT (15 balls)

So starting from the 24-cell alone is insufficient to generate the snub’s projections (24-cell edges ≠ snub edges). The right parent is the 600-cell, and the snub’s two shapes arise from the symmetry- breaking split of the 600-cell’s single H₄ orbit. There are no additional snub projections beyond these two — the search is saturated.

Constructive recipe: diminish the 600-cell zome model

In retrospect, both snub 24-cell zome models can be built directly from the well-known H₄→H₃ zome model of the 600-cell, without any 4D computation:

  1. Start from the standard 75-ball, vertex-first/cell-first projection of the 600-cell (file 600cell/600cell_H4_to_H3.vZome in this repo). This single 3D figure is the only zomeable projection of the 600-cell.

  2. Identify an inscribed regular 24-cell among the 120 vertices of the 600-cell. There are 25 of them. After projection, they fall into 2 H₃-orbits, distinguished by whether the chosen 24-cell contains the vertex on the projection axis (±n):

    Orbit The inscribed 24-cell shadow … Strategy
    (a) on-axis ±n is one of its 24 vertices; shadow is a 15-ball rhombic dodecahedron, completely disjoint from the snub’s 60 balls. “cell-first” snub
    (b) off-axis ±n not in it; shadow is 24 balls of which 18 coincide with snub-vertex projections and only 6 are exclusive to the inscribed 24-cell. “vertex-first” snub
  3. Delete all balls exclusive to the chosen inscribed 24-cell (15 balls for orbit (a); 6 balls for orbit (b)) and every strut incident to a deleted ball. Where a ball is shared (orbit (b)), keep the ball but delete the struts that ran from it to a deleted neighbour.

  4. Result: a valid snub 24-cell zome model.

    • Orbit (a) → the cell-first model, 75 − 15 = 60 balls.
    • Orbit (b) → the vertex-first model, 75 − 6 = 69 balls.

This is a clean post-hoc construction; we only saw it after running the exhaustive 4D search and noticing the 600-cell relation. The saturation guarantee from the search ensures that no third snub zome model exists.

External reference

A photograph of the snub 24-cell cell-first zome model (60 balls, icosahedral outer hull) appears in:

The vertex-first projection does not appear there.

Why this is genuinely new

By the rep-theory argument applied to all Wythoff uniforms, the zomeable kernels of every Wythoffian uniform 4-polytope (47 of them) must be a subset of the kernels for the regular 4-polytopes (empirically confirmed for A₄ in docs/UNIFORM_PLAN.md).

The snub 24-cell, being non-Wythoff, escapes this constraint. Its edges include directions that are not in any F₄-root orbit. The 2 projections found here are thus not realizable as projections of any of the 6 regular 4-polytopes.

Saturation

rng   dirs   hits distinct shapes
3 20474 60 2    
4 135750 100 2    

Saturated at rng=3. Both projections are exactly orthographic (M·Mᵀ eigenvalues all equal to 1.000000000, residual ~1e-15).

Open question

These two shapes use all three default colors with 60+ ball counts. A natural follow-up: do they decompose into recognisable pieces (e.g. icosahedral or rhombicuboctahedral substructures)? Visual inspection in vZome may reveal nested polyhedra.

3D Viewers

➡️ Open this page on GitHub Pages to interact with the 3D models below (the embeds only render when this file is served via GitHub Pages, not in github.com’s markdown preview).

snub_24cell_cell_first.vZome
snub_24cell_vertex_first.vZome